The following information is adapted from American
Chiropractic Association's (ACA's) Proof Positive Brochure Series
Independent Studies Attest to Chiropractic's
Effectiveness
For the past century, doctors of chiropractic have
offered patients relief from numerous types of health
problems, the source of which originated in the back and
spine. Chiropractic procedure has often been successful
when medical treatment has failed. This has been
confirmed by an unlimited number of anecdotal and
clinical experiences.
In recent years, numerous scientific studies have
been conducted throughout the world to determine and
record specifically the effectiveness of chiropractic
care--among them research by non-chiropractic
professionals to provide more objectivity. Following are
synopses of three major studies, which demonstrated
that:
Chiropractic is SAFER
Chiropractic
is LESS COSTLY
Chiropractic
Offers RELIEF.
Chiropractic is:
"Chiropractic manipulation is safer than
medical management of low-back pain."
--The Manga Report
The Manga Report, commissioned by the Ministry of
Health in Ontario, Canada and carried out by leading,
independent health economists at the University of
Ottawa and headed by Pran Manga, PhD, reviewed all of
the international evidence on the management of low-back
pain. It concluded:
- There would be highly
significant cost savings if more management of
low-back pain was transferred from physicians to
chiropractors.
- There should be a "shift
in policy to encourage and prefer chiropractic
services for most patients with low-back pain,"
and chiropractic should "be fully insured (and)
fully integrated" into the Ontario health-care
system.
- "The overwhelming body of
evidence" shows that chiropractic management of
low-back pain is more cost-effective than medical
management, and that "many medical therapies
are of questionable validity or are clearly
inadequate..." It also stated,
"Chiropractic manipulation is safer than
medical management of low-back pain."
- "Chiropractic management
is greatly superior to medical management in terms
of scientific validity, safety, cost-effectiveness
and patient satisfaction."
Chiropractic is:
"Patients that receive chiropractic care,
either solely or in conjunction with medical care
experience significantly lower health-care costs."
--Stano/Medstat Research
Miron Stano, PhD, Oakland University, conducted a
study comparing the health-care costs for chiropractic
and medical patients. The database he used came from the
records of MEDSTAT Systems, Inc., a health benefits
management consulting firm which processes insurance
claims for many of the country's largest corporations.
The database was comprised of 395,641 patients, 42,215
of which were Michigan patients.
After reviewing claims paid over a two-year period,
he concluded:
- Patients who receive
chiropractic care, either solely or in conjunction
with medical care, experienced "significantly
lower health-care costs... on the order of $1,000
each over the two-year period" than those who
received only medical care. Specifically, total
insurance payments were $1,138 (30% higher) for
those who elected medical care only.
- The lower costs for
chiropractic patients were attributable both to lower
in-patient and out-patient costs, and indicated that
"chiropractic treatment substitutes for other
forms of out-patient care."
Chiropractic Offers:
"More than 80% of patients found their
expectations for chiropractic care to be met..."
--Gallup Study
A study by the Gallup Organization, reported in March
1991, was conducted to determine the attitudes,
opinions, and behaviors of both users and non-users of
chiropractic services. Overall, 90% felt that
chiropractic health care was effective: more than 80%
were satisfied with the treatment they received; nearly
75% felt that most of their expectations were met during
the last visit or series of visits; 68% said they would
likely see a doctor of chiropractic again for treatment
of a similar condition, and 50% would likely be willing
to see a doctor of chiropractic for some other problem
chiropractors treat.
Nearly 80% of the chiropractic users felt that the
cost of chiropractic treatment was reasonable.